AMCs: Survey, How Tech Sabotages Appraisers 11-6-26

Newz: Appraiser AMC Survey, AMCs: How Tech Quietly Sabotages Appraisers

November 6, 2026

ARTICLE LIST – In order, Scroll down to read

  • LIA AD: Read The Fine Print
  • Independent Appraiser Voices plus Survey: More in Common Than We Think
  • Inside a Marvel Showrunner’s $2.4 Million Topanga California Compound Featuring a 1970s Geodesic Dome and Private Oak Grove
  • Helping Appraisers Get Paid for What They’ve BuiltBy Isaac Peck, Publisher, WorkingRE
  • My Ad: Major Changes in Fannie Mae’s HBU Property Eligibility Requirements (Effective With UAD 3.6), By Denis Desaix, MAI, SRA
  • Countdown in Chicago: UAD 3.6, AI, and Rates Going Up? MBA 2026 Recap, By Jim Morrison
  • The Full Measure: October 2026 Housing Market Update, By Kevin Hecht, Appraiser and Economist
  • The Ghost in the Machine: How Tech Quietly Sabotages Appraisers, By Desiree Mehbod
  • Appraisers face stagnant pay and rising costs as AMCs defend their fees and new technology reshapes the industry
  • Mortgage Applications Decrease 1.2 Percent in Latest MBA Weekly Survey

Thanks to our Sponsor!!!

Very reasonable prices and good open rates!

———————————————————————–

Independent Appraiser Voices: More in Common Than We Think and and AMC Appraiser Survey

Independent Appraiser Voices is breaking the silence on unfair AMC fees and UAD 3.6 struggles to prove that while we may work independently, we don’t have to face these industry battles alone.

Excerpts: Independent Appraiser Voices is breaking the silence on unfair AMC fees and UAD 3.6 struggles to prove that while we may work independently, we don’t have to face these industry battles alone.

If you’ve been an independent appraiser for any length of time, you’ve probably asked yourself, more than once, “How much more am I expected to take on without being compensated for it?”

Between rising business expenses, increasingly complex assignments, unrealistic deadlines, and AMC fees that often seem disconnected from the work involved, there’s plenty to be frustrated about.

And now we have UAD 3.6. We can probably all agree that the UAD 2.6 forms were due for an update, but is this really the improvement we needed?

We know these frustrations because we’re dealing with them, too. And they’re exactly what inspired Independent Appraiser Voices (IAV). BookAppraisals

IAV is a brand-new, independent grassroots initiative created by working appraisers who believe it’s time to do more than vent about these problems individually. We’re boots-on-the-ground appraisers, just like you, trying to make a living while navigating the same challenges.

There are already people around the country advocating for change in our profession, and we share those goals. We want to bring independent appraisers together, identify the concerns we have in common, and turn our shared experiences into a stronger, more unified voice.

Our first step is the 2026 Independent Appraiser Survey: UAD 3.6, AMC Fees & Industry Concerns.

The survey is anonymous and covers compensation, UAD 3.6, AMC practices, unpaid time, and other industry concerns. There’s no membership, no fee, and nothing being sold. We simply want to hear directly from appraisers across the country.

The survey is anonymous and covers compensation, UAD 3.6, AMC practices, unpaid time, and other industry concerns. There’s no membership, no fee, and nothing being sold. We simply want to hear directly from appraisers across the country.

Our intention is to use the findings to document common concerns, support advocacy for meaningful change, and encourage greater cooperation among independent appraisers. We’ll share the results with the appraisal community and be transparent about what the data does and doesn’t tell us.

To read more, Click Here

To take the survey, Click the link in the article.

My comments: The survey seems like a good idea. I always like to read the survey results. I have never worked for an AMC so did not take the survey.

Read more!! →

AMC Panel Requirements 10-30-26

Newz: UAD 3.6: Fees, Turn-Time, Software and more, AMC Panel Requirements

October 30, 2026

ARTICLE LIST – In order, scroll down the page to read

  • LIA AD: AMC Panel Requirements
  • UAD 3.6: Inside the Struggle Over Fees, Turn-Time and Software By Frank Andorka, Managing Editor WorkingRE
  • A Clifftop Compound With 2 Brand-New Cabins in Idaho Hits the Market
  • What is Highest and Best Use in Appraisal? (Updated for UAD 3.6) , By Kevin Hecht
  • MY AD: What Enough of UAD 3.6, I Have a Business to Run!, By Doug Smith, MBA, SRA
  • UAD 3.6: A New Era of Accountability in Appraisal Quality, By Gynell Vestal (Administrator) American Valuation Society
  • Flock Camera Blunders and the Privacy Risks of UAD 3.6, By Desiree Mehbod
  • MBA stats: Mortgage applications increased 3.4 percent from one week earlier

 

Thanks to our Sponsor!!

——————————-————————-

UAD 3.6: Inside the Struggle Over Fees, Turn-Time, Software and more

By Frank Andorka, Managing Editor, Working RE

Excerpts: Editor’s Note: Since this article was written, the GSEs created an exception to UAD 3.6 implementation for sellers who aren’t able to make the full transition to the new standard before Nov. 2. The exception runs through May 19, 2027. The GSEs will also allow resubmissions of UAD 2.6 appraisal reports through June 27, 2027. As of March 1, 2027, UAD 2.6 appraisals will no longer qualify for certain appraisal-related representations and warranties relief. For more, check out our full report at workingre.com:

GSEs Create Exception for UAD 3.6 Deadline: Runs through May 19, 2027.

To read: Click Here

Nov. 2 is usually just another day on the calendar — but not this year

Timeline and Rollout

The rollout of UAD 3.6 has been hampered considerably by two problems: slow software rollouts and lenders dragging their feet. When Working RE covered Valuation Expo in Las Vegas at the end of August, the problems clearly came into view.

While most of the leading software providers received initial approval from the GSEs in late 2025 and early 2026, word on the ground at Valuation Expo (Val Expo) was that there were still plenty of bugs to work out. AMC executives privately shared that they had staff simultaneously testing all the GSE-approved reporting software so they could troubleshoot and support appraisers when they inevitably ran into problems trying to turn in assignments. Some of those bugs were being run back to the software companies in real time, with the appraiser, AMC, lender and software provider working through the problem together.

The bigger problem in August was that lenders had barely begun ordering the 3.6 appraisals at all. Rocket Mortgage staff at Val Expo said they had ordered six UAD 3.6 appraisals. Rocket originates roughly six to seven percent of all residential mortgages in the United States. Several regional AMCs reported completing exactly two assignments apiece — and in each case, one of the two was a test run the AMC had ordered itself.

Scott Reuter, chief appraiser at Freddie Mac, summed up the bind on a panel at the show: “Appraisers cannot do a 3.6 assignment unless somebody orders a 3.6 assignment.”

More Than 900 Data Elements

There were approximately 190 data elements in UAD 2.6. There are now more than 900 in UAD 3.6. Reuter says it’s easy to be overwhelmed if appraisers just hear the number, but he assures the industry that appraisers were in the room when the form was developed.

“I want to make sure they don’t just hear ‘more than 900 elements’ and worry that they won’t be able to do it,” Reuter says. “They won’t have to fill out all those data points for every property. They are never going to touch the lion’s share of them, but we wanted to make sure we accounted for every potential contingency just in case.”

Lyle Radke, senior director of collateral policy at Fannie Mae, says Fannie and Freddie hold, between the two of them, $7 trillion in mortgage debt which, since it’s backed by the U.S. Treasury, is guaranteed by U.S. taxpayers. Therefore, it stands to reason collecting more data than before is important.

“From that perspective, the data is essential,” Radke says. “It’s how we manage risk. UAD 3.6 makes it easier for us to see and understand the data. If we didn’t have 3.6, we could still parse the data, but it would be much more challenging and time consuming.”

Other topics include turn times, liability and fees.

As the industry rushes toward the Nov. 2 deadline, appraisers’ stress levels will continue to rise. The only question is: What will things look like when the smoke clears? Only time will tell.

To read more, Click Here

My comments: Good discussion of the issues with quotes from many people, including GSEs. Not many changes since the August conference, except software vendors are still sending out updates. Fees still unclear.


Read more!! →

UAD 3.6 Fees for Appraisers 10-16-26

Newz: UAD 3.6 Fees, Fun Appraiser Game, Who Can Get Your Appraisal Data?

October 16, 2026

ARTICLE LIST – In order, Scroll down the page to read

  • LIA AD: Problem with An Affidavit
  • UAD 3.6 and the Appraisal Fee Chain: Who Actually Sets the Fee?, By Doug Smith, SRA
  • Lots Under Water
  • Certification 25: The 20-Year Fight Over Who Gets to Use Your Data, By Isaac Peck, WorkingRE, Publisher
  • Appraiser Game – Something FUN, By Dustin Harris
  • MY AD: 2026 E&O Update – Claims, Payment Options, Lawsuits, Etc
  • Inspectors Blocked the Door, Appraisers handed over the Keys By Desiree Mehbod
  • MBA STATS: Mortgage applications decreased 2.7 percent from one week earlier

 

Thanks to our Sponsor!!!

——————————————————-

UAD 3.6 and the Appraisal Fee Chain: Who Actually Sets the Fee?

By Doug Smith, SRA

“…the higgling and bargaining of the market…”

— Adam Smith, The Wealth of Nations, 1776

There has been considerable discussion about appraisal fees as UAD 3.6 is implemented. Much of the criticism over resistance to fee increases has been directed at Appraisal Management Companies.

But before deciding where responsibility lies, perhaps we need to follow what might be called the appraisal fee chain.

It begins with the borrower

A consumer seeking to purchase or refinance a residence provides information to a lender. The familiar conventional mortgage application is the Uniform Residential Loan Application (URLA), also known as Freddie Mac Form 65/Fannie Mae Form 1003.

For federal mortgage disclosure purposes, an application is considered received once the lender has six pieces of information: the consumer’s name, income, Social Security number, property address, estimated property value, and desired loan amount.

Once those items have been received, the lender generally must provide a Loan Estimate within three business days.

That Loan Estimate includes estimated loan and closing costs, including the anticipated cost of an appraisal when one is required.

This is where the appraisal fee chain gets interesting.

Federal disclosure rules limit how much certain estimated charges can increase between the Loan Estimate and closing. Depending on the circumstances, some required third-party service charges may be subject to a 10% cumulative tolerance, while others are subject to different rules. A valid changed circumstance may also permit a revised Loan Estimate.

So here is the first question:

Does the appraisal amount initially disclosed to the borrower influence the fee that can later be offered to the appraiser?

Once the borrower indicates an intent to proceed, the appraisal ordering process moves forward. Depending on the lender’s business model, the appraisal may be ordered directly from an appraiser or through an AMC.

Eventually, an assignment reaches an appraiser with a proposed fee.

But where in the appraisal fee chain was that number actually established?

Was it established by the lender when estimating the cost of the loan?

Was it established through an existing agreement or fee schedule between the lender and AMC?

Does the AMC determine the fee it offers the appraiser?

For lenders ordering directly, are they expecting UAD 3.6 assignments to be completed for the same fees previously paid for UAD 2.6 assignments?

And when an appraiser responds that the proposed fee is inadequate, how far back up the appraisal fee chain does that information travel?

These questions matter because UAD 3.6 changes the appraisal product and, for many appraisers, the process required to produce it. Appraisers are investing in training, software and equipment. Inspection procedures and data collection are changing. During the transition, the time required to complete an assignment may change as well.

Yet much of the current discussion seems to begin with the assumption that the appraisal fee should remain where it was.

Perhaps the question should not simply be, “Why won’t AMCs increase appraisal fees?”

The better question may be:

Where in the appraisal fee chain is the price of a UAD 3.6 appraisal actually being established—and is there still room for the market to establish a different price?

Nearly 250 years ago, Adam Smith described part of that price-setting process as the “higgling and bargaining of the market.”

Appraisers are participants in that market too.

A proposed fee is a proposal, not necessarily the market price.

Perhaps it is time for a little more higgling and bargaining.

My comments: I had never known about this before. Thanks to Doug Smith for the info!

Read more!! →

Defending Adjustments for Appraisers

Newz:  GSEs Request Feedback on UAD 3.6, Defending Adjustments

September 4 , 2026

What’s in This Newsletter (In Order, Scroll Down)

  • LIA AD: Too Late for a Reconsideration of Value
  • How to Defend Adjustments in Appraisal Reports
  • $112 Million Laguna Beach Mansion With a Private Library and a Rotating Bed in Primary Suite Could Become Priciest Home Ever Sold in Orange County
  • GSEs Request Appraiser Feedback on UAD 3.6
  • MY AD: How AI Can Help Residential Appraisers and Why Appraisers Will Always be Needed By By David Galatto
  • First the Borrower Fee. Now the Appraiser Compensation in Court By Kenneth J. Mullinix
  • The part of the process appraisers never see, and the reason your file keeps coming back
  • UAD 3.6 UPDATE – Inspection Checklist, New Survey: UAD 3.6 mandate is Nov. 2nd. Are you ready for it?,
  • MBA STATS: Mortgage applications increased 0.8 percent from one week earlier

————————————————————————–

How to Defend Adjustments in Appraisal Reports

When someone questions an adjustment, many appraisers respond, “It’s based on market data” or “my experience in the market.” These statements might be true, but they don’t support the adjustment. They just state where it came from.

Appraisal reports are similar to scientific papers. A scientist can’t write “Based on my experiments, the hypothesis is correct” and expect peer review to accept it. Scientists need to share their methodology, summarize their analysis, and support their conclusions.

The same applies to appraisal adjustments. Saying you used market data is like saying you conducted an experiment. It’s just the starting point. Your report needs to summarize how you analyzed the data and how it supports that specific adjustment.

Without this documentation, you haven’t provided credible analysis. You’ve stated an unsupported opinion, regardless of your experience.

You need a clear path from market evidence to the number on your grid. Defending appraisal adjustments isn’t one perfect technique. It’s about using multiple, credible methods, explaining your logic, and sequencing your work so it aligns with how the market behaves and with USPAP.

Below is a practical, step-by-step approach you can put to work right away.

Start with the Right Sequence

Before you calculate any adjustment, get the order right. In practice, you should follow this sequence:

  • Apply transactional adjustments:
  • Real property rights conveyed
  • Financing terms
  • Conditions of sale
  • Expenditures made after purchase
  • Market conditions (time)
  • Apply property adjustments:
  • Location
  • Physical characteristics (e.g., finished square footage, bathrooms, garages, condition, quality)

Transactional adjustments affect the overall transaction price, and each adjustment creates a new base for the next one. They answer the question, “What would this comparable have sold for under typical terms on my effective date?”

These adjustments normalize the sales by removing distortions from unusual financing, non-market conditions, or time differences.

Equalize Market Conditions Before You Compare

Read more!! →

Surplus vs. Excess Land for Appraisers

Newz: Surplus vs. Excess Land,
Easement Issues and Liability

August 14, 2026

What’s in This Newsletter (In Order, Scroll Down)

  • LIA AD: Easements: Issues and Appraiser Liability
  • Surplus Land vs. Excess Land: What Appraisers Need to Know, By Kevin Hecht
  • Built Different: How the Ranch-Style Home Went from 1930s Architectural Rebel to America’s Favorite Floor Plan
  • Let’s Talk About Letters of Engagement, By Jeff Whaley
  • MY AD: UAD 3.6 Software Evaluation Checklist
  • An Abridged History of the Appraiser Profession, By Kendra Budd, Editor Working RE
  • My UAD 3.6 Tips of the Week
  • MBA: Mortgage applications increased 3.6 percent from one week earlier

———————————————————

Surplus Land vs. Excess Land: What Appraisers Need to Know

By Kevin Hecht

Excerpts: Land valuation is a fundamental aspect of real estate appraisal, influencing property transactions, development decisions, and investment strategies. A key part of the process involves distinguishing between the land that supports the property’s current use and any additional land that may or may not have independent value.

Commonly, a square footage adjustment is made based on lot size differences among comparable properties without one key distinction: whether the difference in land is surplus or excess land. This fails to consider whether the extra land has value independent of the subject property.

Surplus land generally does not contribute value beyond its association with the primary parcel, though it may still add some contributory value in certain market conditions. Excess land, by contrast, has value because it can be divided and sold separately.

Understanding this distinction is essential for developing a credible appraisal.

Surplus Land vs. Excess Land at a Glance

Surplus Land – Cannot be separated and sold independently

Excess Land – Can be divided and sold separately

Surplus Land – No independent highest and best use

Excess Land – May have a different highest and best use

Surplus Land – Typically contributes limited additional value

Excess Land – Has independent value and should be analyzed separately

Surplus Land – Remains part of the primary property

Excess Land – Can potentially support separate development

Key Differences Between Surplus and Excess Land

Surplus and excess land apply to commercial and residential properties. Before determining whether land is surplus or excess, appraisers must consider zoning, highest and best use, surrounding properties and their use, property improvements, and supply and demand for the property and any proposed improvements.

Why the Distinction Matters in Appraisal

Choosing the correct land type has an effect on the final value of the property. Excess land adds value to the subject property and creates future potential. Thus, a higher price per square foot should be assigned to excess land over surplus land.

Ultimately, identifying land type is about more than just checking if a property can be split. It’s about understanding the property’s most productive use under current legal and economic conditions.

To read more, Click Here

My comments: Read this article!! The best comprehensive article I have read on this issue. Understanding Surplus vs. Excess Land is critical in appraising. I have encountered this issue mostly in commercial and agricultural appraisals. It can happen in any type of property.

Unfortunately, residential lender appraisers sometimes encounter this but don’t know much about it. I have appraised it on single family properties. Not understanding what this is of the many ways residential appraisers end up trouble at the state appraisal board because of lack of knowledge and experience.

Read more!! →

AQB Exposure Draft Removes College Degree Requirement

Newz: Appraisal Stress Test, AQB Exposure Draft Removes College Degree Requirement

June 26, 2026

What’s in This Newsletter (In Order, Scroll Down)

  • LIA AD: State Board Complaint Frustrations
  • The Appraisal Profession Is Being Stress-Tested. That’s Not the Same as Being Replaced By Jessica Sturm
  • All About the Brownstone: How the Iconic Design Went From Humble Row House Roots to Million-Dollar Metropolis Luxury
  • MY AD: UAD 3.6 Software Evaluation Checklist By Doug Smith
  • Include E&O in Appraisal Reports? Just Say No By Isaac Peck
  • AQB second exposure draft removes college degree requirement
  • MBA STATS: Mortgage applications increased 1.0 percent from one week earlier     
  • ———————————————————

 

The Appraisal Profession Is Being Stress-Tested.

That’s Not the Same as Being Replaced

A frank conversation about UAD 3.6, waiver expansion, and where the real opportunity lies.

By Written by : Jessica Sturm, EVP of Property Services at Opteon.

Excerpts:

What UAD 3.6 Actually Changes (And What It Doesn’t)

UAD 3.6 changes the infrastructure around how appraisal judgment is captured, structured, and delivered. It does not change what a great appraiser does and the value they bring. Your ability to walk a property and know, as a trained professional, that the finished basement wasn’t permitted, that the kitchen renovation was done on the cheap or that the comparable three streets over sold under pressure. None of that local, industry expertise lives in a data schema.

What the new standard demands is that the mechanics around that judgment are handled cleanly and consistently. Field data capture, structured commentary, condition ratings, quality flags, all in a format that downstream systems can use. That’s not a threat to expertise. We see this as a long-overdue investment in the infrastructure that supports our industry.

What the Stress Test Is Really Asking

Every industry stress test asks the same question: who is built for what comes next?

UAD 3.6 is asking whether the profession can operate with greater rigor and efficiency. Waiver expansion is asking whether appraisers can own the complex, high stakes, advisory end of the market with real authority. The mature appraiser pipeline is asking whether the profession can retain experience and retrain while bringing in and developing new people. These are hard questions, but the profession has more tools, more data, and more support to answer them than at any point in its history.

Accounting faced the same reckoning. When tax software arrived and then matured, the prediction was that it would hollow out the profession. Routine compliance work did automate and what happened next was the opposite of collapse.

To read more, Click Here

My comments: Interesting analysis. I think the new reports are much better than the old forms for reviewers and borrowers. If I was doing GSE appraisals I would look forward to doing them.

Read more!! →

Recent Executive Orders Affecting Appraisers

Newz: Recent Executive Orders Affecting    Appraisers, When Appraisers Take the Stand

June 12, 2026

What’s in This Newsletter (In Order, Scroll Down)

  • LIA AD: A case of forgery
  • Recent Executive Orders: Threat, Opportunity, or Both for Appraisers? By Kim Perotti, AXIS AMC
  • $22.8 Million Aspen Home With Its Own Private Waterfall Feels Like a Real-Life Fairy Tale
  • MY AD: If the Standards Are Uniform, Why Isn’t Your License? By Thaddus Dawson, Jr., CG
  • When Appraisers Take the Stand By By David C. Wilkes, Esq., CRE, FRICS and Kevin M. Clyne, Esq., CRE
  • Agents, Are You Using AI to Price Your Listings? By Tom Horn
  • 10K Appraisers. Policy and Advocacy Day, By 10K Appraisers Foundation
  • MBA: Mortgage applications increased 10.8 percent from one week earlier

Recent Executive Orders: Threat, Opportunity, or Both for Appraisers?

By Kim Perotti, a founding partner of AXIS AMC

Excerpts: In March 13, 2026, President Trump signed two Executive Orders that together amount to a clear message for our profession: build more houses, make credit easier, and get the valuation piece done faster and cheaper. We think it’s critically important that our industry discuss the implications.

The two orders are:

REMOVING REGULATORY BARRIERS TO AFFORDABLE HOME CONSTRUCTION

AND PROMOTING ACCESS TO MORTGAGE CREDIT

While they are not “about” appraisers, the Executive Orders will absolutely reshape the environment in which we work. Appraisers who treat these as background noise will find the ground shifting under their feet. Those who read them as a roadmap can pick their spots and come out stronger and, more importantly, help shape how they are put into practice.

REMOVING REGULATORY BARRIERS TO AFFORDABLE HOME CONSTRUCTION:

Faster, Cheaper Construction – What That Really Means for Your Desk

PROMOTING ACCESS TO MORTGAGE CREDIT: Faster, Cheaper Valuations – Where the Squeeze Shows Up – Second Order

The second order takes direct aim at how loans—and valuations—get done. The theme is unmistakable: streamline, digitize, and de-emphasize technical compliance.

For appraisers, here are the potential realities:

More alternative valuation products: Regulators are being encouraged to expand the use of AVMs, desktop, and hybrid appraisals and reduce full appraisal requirements on low-risk and small-balance loans. You should expect more hybrid and desktop requests and data-only products as well as a clearer dividing line between high-volume, low-margin work and complex, higher-risk assignments.

Pressure on fees and turn times: Agencies are being asked to set “clear appraisal timelines” and cut costs and therefore lenders will likely lean harder on speed and price whenever a waiver, AVM, or hybrid is allowed, and traditional assignment ordering will have to justify itself on risk grounds.

Changes in who can appraise and how: The order invites simplification of appraiser qualification requirements. Easier entry could mean more competitors and lenders may fill low-fee niches with less-experienced personnel or non-traditional vendors.

If your business is built primarily on simple, low-risk assignments, this is a direct competitive challenge.

Alignment of FHA and VA rules: HUD and VA are asked to align standards where risk is comparable, clarify what truly requires pre-closing repairs vs. what’s cosmetic, and expand post-closing repair flexibility.

That could change the frequency and scope of “subject to” conditions, reduce some friction and disputes around FHA/VA appraisals, and make your judgment about safety vs. cosmetic issues more visible and important.

In summation, this order calls for more technology and alternatives, more pressure on traditional appraisals, and more segmentation of valuation products by risk level.

A Clear Fork in the Road for Appraisers

Taken together, these two Executive Orders point in one direction: more volume, more complexity at the edges of the market, and more pressure to commoditize anything that looks “low risk.” Together they create a fork in the road for real estate appraisers:

If you stay in the lane of interchangeable, low-complexity assignments, you will feel the squeeze—from technology, from relaxed standards, and from new entrants.

If you lean into complexity—new construction, manufactured and modular, fringe markets, environmental and hazard issues, FHA/VA nuance—you become harder to replace, not easier.

This doesn’t mean abandoning efficiency or refusing alternative products. It means being fluent in hybrids and desktops so you can decide which work makes sense for you, positioning yourself as the expert when a lender can’t responsibly rely on an AVM or a waiver, and building documented expertise in the exact areas these orders will expand.

To read more, Click Here

My comments: Definitely worth reading. All about what this means for appraisers in detail. The best analysis for appraisers I have read about this executive order. The author is definitely an “insider” as she is Co President of AXIS, a long time AMC. When I wrote one of my first articles on AMCs, I interviewed AXIS.

Read more!! →

24 Hour Appraisals

Newz: 24 Hour Appraisals, Bias Accusation Collapses, Easements and Appraiser Liability

May 15, 2026

What’s in This Newsletter (In Order, Scroll Down)

  • LIA AD: Easements and Appraiser Liability
  • 24-Hour Appraisals: The Future or a Gimmick? By Shawn Telford , Chief Appraiser and Valuation Officer at Cotality
  • $28 Million ‘Pavilion’ House in Los Angeles Boasts ‘Once-in-a-Generation’ Design—and a Sunken Conversation Pit
  • Freddie/Fannie UAD and Forms Redesign: Enhanced Timeline and Updated FAQs
  • MY AD: Appraisal forms software in September, 1993 – a glance at the past
  • AQB Releases White Paper on Experience Requirements
  • Bias Accusation Collapses as HUD Clears the Appraiser by Desiree Mehbod
  • MBA: Mortgage applications increased 1.7 percent from one week earlier

 

—————————————————————————

24-Hour Appraisals: The Future or a Gimmick?

By Shawn Telford , Chief Appraiser and Valuation Officer at Cotality,

Rethinking Quality and Risk in Modern Valuations: Why Faster Can be Risky

Excerpts: side from the opinion of value, speed is often the next loudest talking point in any conversation about appraisals—but it’s also one of the most misleading. While accelerated appraisal procurement models promise faster turn times, they do little to address the concerns that matter most to lenders: inaccurate valuations, which lead to appraisal defects that create buyback exposure and margin pressures for lenders, ultimately contributing to delays and additional costs.

This isn’t to say that the prospect of 24-hour appraisals is not appealing: after all, who doesn’t like faster? But is it a game-changer or merely a gimmick?

Today, lenders are facing greater scrutiny from the GSEs and investors over loan quality, in general, and collateral valuations in particular. Recently, Fannie Mae reported that collateral defects – like property damage, appraisal condition & quality rating inflation, and inappropriate comparable sale selection—are now accounting for nearly half of discretionary loan review defects. Solving for the Right Problems

Pressuring appraisers to work faster is hardly going to address these issues.

The Economic Impact of Quality

Getting an appraisal quickly can be a plus. But if the valuation requires extensive rework, it can create friction and delays and add operational costs to the underwriting process. One of the biggest slowdowns in the appraisal process is the back-and-forth between the appraiser and an AMC’s lender over administrative “corrections” that often don’t affect the opinion of value. In fact, recent Cotality data shows that nearly half of all appraisals are returned for some type of correction, and the vast majority of those returned do not have their value changed when resubmitted.

To read more, Click Here

My comments: very good analysis with many excellent comments. Very knowledgeable author. Worth reading.


Read more!! →

The Appraiser Exodus and How to Fix It

Newz: Expanded Intended Users?

The Appraiser Exodus and How to Fix It.

May 8, 2026

What’s in This Newsletter (In Order, Scroll Down)

  • LIA AD: Expanding Intended Users? Not So Fast
  • Under Pressure: What’s Driving the Appraiser Exodus and How to Fix It, By David Massey
  • Historic Tudor Estate With English Gardens and Prairie Views Is Listed for $4.7 Million Near Chicago
  • What is a Pre-listing appraisal? Written for Home Owners But Has Good Tips for Appraisers, By Tom Horn
  • MY AD: What Happened When Government Decided That Appraisers Needed Protection, By Cindy Chance, PhD
  • How to See the Potential in Homes That Don’t Look Perfect. Written for Home Owners But Has Good Tips for appraisers
  • More Than 60% of America Is Covered by Drought and Millions of Homes Are at Risk
  • UAD 3.6 Bootcamp, LIVE in Chicago, IL and on Zoom, Wednesday – Friday, May 13th-15th
  • MBA STATS: Mortgage applications decreased 4.4 percent from one week earlier

 

——————————————————————-

Under Pressure: What’s Driving the Appraiser Exodus and How to Fix It,

By David Massey

Ask any veteran appraiser or physician what has changed most over the past twenty years, and the answer is usually the same: paperwork.

Professions once centered on skill, judgment, and service are now dominated by portals, compliance layers, and third-party control. Burnout rises, independence falls, and a quiet exodus follows.

The American Medical Association reports that physicians now spend nearly two hours on documentation for every hour of patient care.

The appraisal profession is now well into that cycle.

According to the Appraisal Institute’s 2023 Fact Sheet, the number of practicing appraisers in the United States has declined by roughly 8,000 in recent years. The Conference of State Bank Supervisors shows a longer-term drop from about 120,000 appraisers in 2008 to fewer than 96,000 by 2017, a 21 percent decline in less than a decade. IBISWorld reports another six percent employment drop between 2018 and 2023. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics projects only modest growth through 2034, far short of what is needed to replace retirees.

The pipeline is shrinking while demand remains steady.

The National Association of Realtors ® 2023 Appraisal Survey found that more than half of appraisers are now asked monthly, or more often, to complete assignments outside their normal geographic or property-type expertise. More telling, 54 percent cited Appraisal Management Companies as the single greatest challenge to their business. That statistic alone explains much of what has gone wrong.

When I started in this profession, appraisal centered on analysis, interpretation, and professional opinion. I studied neighborhoods, walked properties, and applied experience to market behavior. Today, much of the job revolves around compliance portals, redundant uploads, and layers of review by people who have never inspected a property.

AMCs were created after the 2008 crisis to protect appraiser independence. The idea made sense. The execution has failed. Today, borrowers commonly pay $600 to $700 for an appraisal, while the appraiser often receives about half of that after AMC fees. Turn times lengthen. Panel depth shrinks. Geographic competency erodes. And experienced appraisers quietly step away.

What was meant to reduce pressure has become a system of control. Communication between lenders and appraisers is filtered. Pricing is dictated by algorithms. Scope interpretations are issued by third parties removed from the field. Judgment is slowly replaced by checklist compliance.

Healthcare has already traveled this road.

A 2025 Annals of Internal Medicine study showed nearly five percent of U.S. physicians left clinical practice in a single year, driven largely by burnout and administrative burden. The American Medical Association reports that physicians now spend nearly two hours on documentation for every hour of patient care.

Appraisers now operate inside the same imbalance. More time formatting reports than analyzing markets. More time satisfying review protocols than developing defensible opinions. Judgment yields to process.

This is not a workforce inconvenience. It is a structural market risk.

The fix is not complicated, but it does require courage.

First, appraisal fee transparency must be mandatory. If a borrower pays $650 and the appraiser receives $325, both parties deserve to know. Transparency restores accountability and allows market forces to function.

To read more, Click Here

My comments: Worth reading, especially how to fix it. We all know what is happening to residential lender appraisers.

For doctors, corporate medicine has taken over. For example, primary care physicians are allowed only 15 minute visits with patients. Large insurance companies make it very difficult for patients to get the care they need by denying what the patient needs. Doctors don’t like it, plus the excessive paperwork.

I play pickleball with a retired doctor. He had to sell his medical practice as he was underbid on fees by large health insurance companies.

Read more!! →

Avoiding Court: A Common Sentiment Among Appraisers

Newz: Cyber Attack Risk for Appraisers,

Avoiding Court: A Common Sentiment Among Appraisers

May 1, 2026

What’s in This Newsletter (In Order, Scroll Down)

  • LIA AD: Avoiding Court: A Common Sentiment Among Appraisers
  • Cyber Insurance: Why It’s Time for Appraisers to Protect Themselves By Isaac Peck, Senior Broker at OREP.org
  • Electrochemist’s Exclusive Private Island Escape With 9-Hole Golf Course and Helipad Hits the Market in Florida for $89 Million
  • Hype Heretics – Twisting the narrative to create hype. By JoAnn Apostol
  • MY AD: What is a Good Appraiser?
  • April 2026 Housing Insights: A Market Searching for Stability, By Kevin Hecht, Appraiser and Economist
  • A new Scope of Work, By George Dell, MAI
  • MBA: Mortgage applications decreased 1.6 percent from one week earlier

——————————————-

 

—————————————————

Cyber Insurance: Why It’s Time for Appraisers to Protect Themselves

By Isaac Peck, Senior Broker at OREP.org

Excerpts: You log in, expecting to send a report or check your schedule for the coming week, only to find your system locked, client files gone, and a message blinking on the screen:

“YOUR FILES ARE ENCRYPTED

To regain access, you must pay a ransom. Do not attempt to decrypt or modify the files yourself.

Any unauthorized action will result in permanent data loss.

Payment instructions are below. You have 72 hours.”

Directly below the words, a clock begins counting down.

You feel panic setting in.

To make matters worse, you had committed to delivering a rush appraisal to the lender/AMC this morning for a time-sensitive closing. You can’t access reports, contact clients, or meet deadlines. You’re losing money, time, and worst of all, your clients’ trust.

Directly below the words, a clock begins counting down.

This type of mentality only compounds the problem. According to recent national data, more than half of U.S. cyberattacks now target small businesses, not large corporations. Firms with fewer than 100 employees are significantly more likely to be targeted than larger companies, largely because they lack dedicated IT staff, formal security protocols, and incident-response plans. In other words, they’re easier targets.

The financial consequences are not theoretical. According to Verizon’s 2024 Data Breach Investigations Report, small business data breaches can cost anywhere from $120,000 to over $1.2 million, depending on severity. Other industry studies released this summer put the average cost of a single cyber incident at roughly $25,000—far more than most appraisal businesses can absorb without serious disruption.

Unique Risks for Appraisers

Home appraisers face unique cyber risks that make them especially vulnerable to digital attacks. Unlike larger firms with dedicated IT teams, most appraisers operate as solo practitioners or small businesses.

Nevertheless, even the smallest appraisal offices handle highly sensitive data every day: property details, borrower information, lender communications, and access credentials all flow through their systems, often via unsecured emails or cloud-based platforms.

The Role of Insurance

When a cyber incident hits, speed matters. For appraisers, the real damage often isn’t just the ransom demand or the technical cleanup—it’s the downtime, the missed deadlines, and the loss of client confidence that follows.

Cyber insurance exists to help businesses recover quickly and responsibly. For appraisers, that means having access to technical experts who can investigate what happened, contain the breach, and restore systems so work can resume. It also means guidance on how to communicate with lenders, clients, and other parties if sensitive information is compromised.

To read more, Click Here

My comments: Read this article. I have received information from several appraiser E and and O companies about cyber insurance. And read about the risks online. This article is definitely the best I have read as it explains the details of what a cyber attack means for appraisers. Since it was from an E and O carrier I did not know how much useful information it had. I’m glad I read it and wrote about it.

Read more!! →